Best eyeliner for Tightlining Sensitive Eyes in 2023

Eyeliner is one makeup item where most people go overboard. It can really add volume, definition and drama to your eyes. However, for some people with sensitive eyes, eyeliner can be a real pain. That’s why we’ve put together this list of the 9 best eyeliners for tightlining sensitive eyes. Whether you’re looking for a waterproof formula that won’t smudge or a formula that’s easy to apply and delivers long-lasting results, we’ve got you covered. So why not give one of these eyeliners a try this week and see the difference for yourself?

Best Eyeliner for Tightlining Sensitive Eyes

1. Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen :

Finding the perfect eyeliner for a long day wear has never been easier than with Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen. This unique formula glides on effortlessly, leaving a precise line that’s long-lasting and easy to remove.

Available in Pitch Black, this innovative formula is formulated with advanced technologies to deliver intense color that won’t smudge or fade for up to 24 hours. Designed for sensitive eyes and contact lenses, this versatile liquid liner is the perfect addition to your makeup bag.

2.VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil 

Say goodbye to digging your eyes out in the morning and hello to a new favorite product! This Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil is formulated for sensitive eyes that need comfort without compromising long-wear.

It’s also vegan-friendly, never tested on animals, paraben free, and gluten-free. The dermatologist and ophthalmologist-approved formula is safe for use on delicate eye areas with no harsh chemicals. Now you can have the perfect smoky eye without worrying about irritation or allergies!

3. L’Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner

L’Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner caters to the needs of aging skin. The lightweight, waterproof formula makes for easy application and comfortable wear.

Dermatologically tested, the mineral pigments ensure that sensitive eyes are protected from any irritation caused by eye makeup.

The precise tip allows for smooth and easy application without tugging or smudging. With its convenient shape, this eyeliner pencil is perfect for creating a precise wing or lining your eyes in a classic cat-eye style.

4. Physicians Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil Ultra Black

Waterproof? Check. Densely pigmented? Check. And that’s not all; this pencil comes with a built-in sharpener on the bottom so you’re good to go!

Apply it as eyeliner or smudge it for a more natural look, and remove it by using Physicians Formula’s Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil. Whether you’re going for a classic cat eye or something more daring, this eyeliner pencil is sure to give your eyes wings.

5. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Liner Pencil

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil is an intense color that lasts all day. Made with a smooth and creamy formula, it glides on easily without tugging or creasing. It is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes. Don’t forget to pick up a few shades so you can create your own unique look!

 6. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner

Forget the old school liquid eyeliner. This little beauty packs a serious punch. With its super-black pigmentation, you can create an intense winged line or a soft smoky eye that lasts throughout the day.

The applicator ensures even application and easy blending. And because it’s formulated without parabens, silicones, and other nasties, your eyes are sure to be safe and protected by this exfoliating formula. Don’t stress over trying to find the perfect black liquid liner any longer – Honest Beauty has you covered!

7. LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Inkcredible Precise Gel Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

Enhance your eye shape with this incredible gel eyeliner. Give your eyes the oomph you desire with laura geller inkcredible gel waterproof smudge-proof eyeliner pencil with built-in sharpener! From black to brown to purple, choose a shade that matches your desired look.

With its creamy texture, you can easily glide it on for an intense and smudge-proof finish. Not only is it long lasting but also this is one of the best waterproof eyeliners for sensitive eye tightlining.

Whether you’re dressing up for an evening out or going casual everyday style, add some extra glam to your appearance with this One Stroke Wonder!

8. Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner

The Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner is a great choice for your sensitive eye area. Made with Jojoba, Mango, and Meadow foam Seed Oils, the product aims to nourish and hydrate your eyes while providing long-lasting coverage.

The unique cedar wood pencil is also responsibly sourced, so you can feel good about using it on your eyes.

Midnight Gray is one of three natural shades available, perfect for complementing blue, green or brown eyes! This is the best eyeliner for contact lens wearers and safe product for skin tones too.

9. COOSA Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil Set 20 Colors Natural Matte Long Lasting Eyeliners Eye Makeup Pencils

COOSA Waterproof Matte Eye Makeup Pencils is a quality eyeliner that’s perfect for creating your own dramatic eye makeup look. With the highly pigmented formula and waterproof nature of the product, you can create your desired eyes with ease.

Plus, because this eyeliner set is sweat-resistant, you won’t have to worry about it running or smudging throughout the day. This is also a great option if you’re looking for something that’s both affordable and easy-to-use.

Whether you’re wearing it on its own or creating other looks with it, COOSA Waterproof Matte Eye Makeup Pencils will provide you with everything you need to make an impact at any event!

Why Choose Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes?

Eyeliner is one of the most versatile makeup products out there. It can be used for a myriad of looks and can be worn during the day without fear of it smudging or flaking off. If you’re tightening sensitive eyes, make sure to choose an eyeliner that’s sensitive-friendly.

There are a variety of liner types available, from water-proof to smudge-proof, and you can find one that’s perfect for your sensitive eyes. Some people choose to tightline with eyeliner alone – if this is you, make sure to choose an eyeliner that’s sensitive-friendly so the tightlining process is smooth and easy.

Finally, tightlining is a popular eyelid technique that can help you create a tighter eyelid appearance. So go ahead and give it a try!

Tightlining vs Eyeliner :

-Tightlining is the process of applying eyeliner to the lash line, in order to create a more intense eye look.

-Eyeliner is typically used as a base for eyeshadow, Contouring or Liner application.

Pros of Tightlining :

-Allows for more intense eyeshadow application, liner or contouring.

-Can be worn during the day without fear of smudging or running.

-More precise eyeliner application – no water line to smudge! 🙂

-Can be used to create a tight eyelid appearance.

Cons of Tightlining :

-More time-consuming and requires more practice.

5 Things to Consider When Choosing Eyeliner for Tightlining Sensitive Eyes

Eyeliner can be a tricky thing to use, especially if you have sensitive eyes. That’s why it’s important to consider the following when choosing the best eyeliner for tightlining sensitive eyes:

Pigment Strength

Eyeliner is an essential makeup product for any woman. However, the choice of eyeliner can be daunting if you don’t know how to pick the best one for your skin tone and eye makeup look.

To make choosing easier, we’ve put together some tips on pigment strength, brush tip size and water-resistant nature. Once you have everything figured out, it’s time to line those eyes!

The Right Brush

There are a range of different types and colors of liquid liners to choose from, as well as waterproof options and liner brushes with soft bristles.

It’s important to find the perfect eyeliner for your eyelashes – try out different types before settling on one, and make sure the brush is gentle enough not to cause irritation.

Finally, make sure the size of the bristle is small enough so you don’t end up smudging your eyeshadow underneath!

The Right Formula

When it comes to eyeliner, the right formula is key. A waterproof and long-lasting liner should be easy to apply while still blending evenly. Choosing a light but the bold formula will give definition while the color should not irritate sensitive eyes.

Experiment until you find your perfect formula

When it comes to makeup, the best formula is the one that works best for you. Take your time to experiment with different shades and formulas until you find the one that suits your eye color and skin tone perfectly.

In addition, be sure to choose a makeup liner made specifically for sensitive eyes- otherwise irritation might occur.

Lastly, make sure the eyeliner formula is easy enough to apply without causing irritation- this will help avoid any problems in the long run!

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is waterlining and tightlining?

A: The technique of waterlining is used to create eyeliner on the inside of the lower eyelid margin, close against the lashes.

 Tightlining is a technique of applying eyeliner to the top lashes, which is similar to waterlining (drawing your eyeliner along the eye’s waterline).

Q: Why do people tightline?

A: There are many reasons why people opt to tightline their eyes- from adding an extra bit of definition to the lash line, to creating a mascara-proof eyeliner look. Ultimately, the goal is to create a dramatic and long-lasting eye makeup look.

Q: Is tight lining bad for your eyes ?

A: No, tight lining eyeliner can actually be good for your eyes. It makes the eyes look larger and more awake which is why it’s often used by makeup artists. Tightlining eyeliner can be tricky for those with sensitive eyes, so it is important to choose the right eyeliner formula if you want to avoid any irritation.

Q: How to remove tightline eyeliner?

A: If you decide that you no longer want to wear tightline eyeliner, there are a few easy steps that you can follow. First, use ophthalmologist-grade eye makeup remover to remove the liner completely- this should work best if the liner is waterproof. If the liner isn’t waterproof, try using a mild eye makeup remover and slowly wipe it off starting from the inside of your lash line towards the outside (avoid rubbing eyes). Be particularly careful with waterline liners- these may be more difficult to remove than other types of eyeliner.

Q: How do tightline sensitive eyes ?

Apply plenty of gel liner to the base of lashes without putting too much pressure. The most difficult part will be staying open, but take breaks when you feel like you’re about to weep or rip your eyelids apart. Laura Merciers tightlining powder, which is fantastic for staying on even if you get a little teary, is another option if that doesn’t work.

Q: Does eye makeup make my eyes more sensitive to tightlining?

A: There is no scientific evidence that eye makeup makes your eyes more sensitive to tightlining. However, some people may feel uncomfortable applying eyeliner because it can be too harsh on the skin. In the case of tightlining, if you’re experiencing discomfort, then it’s always best to speak with your doctor first before making any decisions about makeup or tightlining.

Q: Is there a difference between waterproof and long-lasting eyeliners?

A: There is no definitive answer to the question as it depends on the individual’s preferences. However, waterproof eyeliners are generally seen as being better as they will stay put all day long and prevent any irritation or residue build-up. Long-lasting eyeliners, meanwhile, are perfect for tightlining – just make sure to test it out first before using it on your eyes.

Q: How To Select The Right Tightline Eyeliner?

A: There are a few factors to consider when selecting the best tightline eyeliner for sensitive eyes. First, you’ll want to make sure the liner doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals or irritants.

Some of the best eyeliners on the market don’t have any harsh ingredients and can be used by those with sensitive eyes without issue.

Secondly, you’ll want to find an eyeliner that’s easy to apply- even if you’re tightlining for the first time.

Many of the best tightline eyeliners come in liquid form which makes it easy to line your eyes without making mistakes.


There are a few tips that you can use to help select the right tightline eyeliner for your sensitive eyes. First, make sure to choose an eyeliner formula that doesn’t contain any ingredients that could be harmful or uncomfortable. Second, try out different line widths and styles until you find the one that’s perfect for you. And finally, keep in mind the eye area where you plan on applying the tightlining- this will help ensure that the liner stays put all night long!

Q: What eyeliner is safe to use on waterline?

A: Eyeliner that you use on the waterline should be waterproof pencil eyeliner. Brand that is known for this like the L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof, Up to 24HR Pencil Eyeliner.

When it comes to eyeliner, the safest option is to choose a product that is fragrance-free and oil-free. These types of eyeliner are best suited for people with sensitive skin as they will reduce inflammation and fatigue around your eyes. Some of the ingredients used in these products are aloe vera juice, vitamin E oil and Titanium Dioxide which helps to improve the appearance of eye area wrinkles.


Eyeliner is one of the most versatile makeup tools. When choosing the best eyeliner for tightlining sensitive eyes, make sure to consider the following factors: the type of eyeliner, the water-resistant formula, the applicator tip, and the texture. Have fun trying out different eyeliners that are designed specifically for sensitive eyes and let us know which one is your favorite in the comments below!

Leave a Comment